Research Mentor Name

Manoj Kulchania

Research Mentor Email Address

manoj.kulchania@wayne.edu

Institution / Department

Wayne State University School of Medicine, Mike Ilitch School of Business

Document Type

Research Abstract

Research Type

medicaleducation

Level of Research

yes

Type of Post-Bachelor Degree

M.D./M.B.A

Abstract

The Financial Implications of Medical Education: An ROI Analysis of School Type, Specialty, and Training Location

Introduction

The financial burden of medical education profoundly influences career trajectories and long-term financial outcomes for physicians. This study examined the impact of medical school costs (comparing an in-state public and private medical school), specialty selection (focusing on Pediatrics, OB/GYN, and Orthopedic Surgery), and geographic factors on physicians' financial returns. Further, this study considered loan repayment strategies and their effects on career return on investment (ROI), offering insights into financial decision-making for future medical graduates.

Methods

Data on medical school costs, including tuition and cost of living (COA), were collected from information publicly published on schools’ websites. An annual tuition increase of 3.5% was assumed based on historic trends. Three payment scenarios were analyzed: 100% cash, 50/50 cash-loan split, and 100% loans. In forecasting costs, we assumed an 8% interest rate in line with current interest rates. Multiple repayment strategies were analyzed, starting with a 10% salary repayment and progressing to more aggressive plans aimed at repaying loans over 40, 23, or 15 years of practice. Physician salary data, retrieved from Medscape, informed ROI calculations, with consideration to varied tax rates and loan repayment schedules. ROI was compared across school types, specialties, and repayment strategies. ROI was defined as the total career income divided by the aggregate net loan payments.

Results

Public in-state institutions, such as Wayne State University, yielded higher ROI compared to private schools, especially for lower-paying specialties like Pediatrics. Orthopedic surgeons experienced the highest ROI across repayment strategies, with aggressive 15-year repayment plans yielding ROIs of up to 2638%, compared to 524% for 40-year plans. Pediatrics showed limited ROI gains due to lower salaries, though repayment strategies significantly influenced financial outcomes.

Discussion

Loan repayment timelines emerged as a critical determinant of financial outcomes. While aggressive repayment reduced interest costs and improved ROI, it imposed greater financial strain early in physicians' careers. Public medical schools offered better financial returns due to lower initial costs, particularly for specialties with modest to high compensation. Specialty choice was also an important consideration for ROI, although its impact was somewhat reduced due to the longer training required. Certain limitations may slightly temper these findings, including the exclusion of loan forgiveness programs, investment opportunities, and non-financial benefits of prestigious institutions.

Conclusion

The cost of medical education, specialty choice, and loan repayment strategies significantly affect physicians’ financial trajectories. Aggressive repayment strategies and studying at public institutions improve ROI, though personal factors and career goals should guide decision-making. Future research should incorporate broader financial variables and explore non-monetary factors shaping physicians’ career choices.

Disciplines

Finance and Financial Management | Medical Education | Medicine and Health Sciences

Download

Share

COinS